The U.K. stands at its most dangerous crossroads in decades after Parliament emphatically rejected Theresa May’s Brexit deal and left her facing an uncomfortable vote to oust her government.

The humiliating defeat on Tuesday evening, the biggest for any government in modern history, leaves May’s divorce agreement with the European Union all but dead and opposition leader Jeremy Corbyn trying to force a general election. While May believes she will survive Wednesday’s no-confidence vote, it’s unclear how long she -- or her Brexit strategy -- will last.

With the U.K. due to leave the EU in 10 weeks, there is growing alarm among British and European politicians that May will fail to end the impasse in time to avoid the potential economic catastrophe of leaving the EU without a deal. Any alternatives, including calling a second referendum, would likely require the EU to extend the March 29 departure deadline.

The prime minister said she will start cross-party talks this week to try to reach a consensus, but in such a febrile atmosphere they may already be doomed. Corbyn dismissed her offer as too little, too late.

The dramatic, if not unexpected, events in the House of Commons marked another watershed for a country that used to be a pillar of democratic stability and is now at the mercy of the divisions sown by the 2016 referendum to leave Europe’s common market after 46 years of membership.

Embedded Image
An anit-Brexit demonstrator reacts to the result of the vote on the Brexit deal in London, U.K., on Tuesday, Jan. 15, 2019. (Simon Dawson/Bloomberg)

Landslide Loss

May lost the vote on approving her Brexit deal by 432 to 202. Giving her reaction afterward, she was barely able to contain her frustration.

“It is clear that the House does not support this deal,” May told the Commons. “But tonight’s vote tells us nothing about what it does support -- nothing about how -- or even if -- it intends to honor the decision the British people took in a referendum Parliament decided to hold.”

Opposition to the deal has focused on the backstop designed to keep the Irish border open, which anti-EU members of May’s Tory Party fear would permanently trap the U.K. in the bloc’s customs union. Members of Parliament have also objected to the size of the cash settlement for the EU and the level of access to European markets after the split.

If May loses Wednesday’s no-confidence vote, Britain will be on course for its third general election in four years. Many Conservatives on her side who voted against the Brexit deal said they’d support her leadership. If everyone on her side does turn out, her margin of safety is just 13 votes. On Tuesday night, 118 members of her party voted against her deal.

A loss like that would finish off a prime minister in normal times. But these aren’t normal times.

Embedded Image
In this image issued by the House of Commons of British Prime Minister Theresa May speaks in the House of Commons in London after losing a vote on her Brexit plan Tuesday Jan. 15, 2019. (Mark Duffy, House of Commons via AP)

Stop Pretending

The mood in Parliament after the vote was surprisingly upbeat. Many members have been waiting months for the chance to vote on Brexit. They were denied their moment in December, when May pulled the vote. Now, they said, May could stop pretending that her deal had a chance of passing and move to discussing more realistic options.

The first sign of this was immediately after the vote, when the prime minister bowed to pressure from Cabinet colleagues and said she would open talks with opposition parties.

But Andrea Leadsom, leader of the House of Commons, made clear on Wednesday that May’s preference is to talk to senior rank-and-file Labour MPs rather than the party’s leadership. Labour’s economy spokesman John McDonnell complained the premier had not reached out to Corbyn.

“What Jeremy Corbyn wants to do is disrupt government and disrupt the nation at a crucial time by seeking a general election,” Leadsom told BBC Radio. “The prime minister will speak with senior parliamentarians across the House and seek to find a way that meets with a majority.” May’s deal is still the “basis” for reaching that consensus, she said.

Where Now?

The question is what that route forward looks like.

For now at least, May is sticking to the principles she’s set out already, while her aides insist that the Withdrawal Agreement she negotiated with the EU over the past two years can’t be allowed to die. While she’s not yet publicly contemplating extending the Brexit deadline, May gave a heavy hint she won’t allow the U.K. to crash out of the bloc.

“I have always believed that the best way forward is to leave in an orderly way with a good deal,” she said.

Some in May’s Conservatives back a no-deal Brexit, and urged her to take that route. Others favor a customs union with the EU. There might be a majority for that -- it’s the position the Labour Party supports -- but were May to go for it, she would risk angering even more Conservatives.

Realistically, May will have to at least invite Corbyn to talk, though his office said on Tuesday evening that there was no future for anything based on May’s deal.

Embedded Image
Customers watch a television news report on the U.K. Parliament Brexit vote at a pub in the Westminster district of London, U.K., on Tuesday, Jan. 15, 2019. ( Simon Dawson/Bloomberg)

Labour Pressure

For now, Labour’s priority is its attempt to trigger a general election by persuading seven of May’s side to rebel and back their motion. If, as expected, that fails, there was little sign from Corbyn’s office that he’s about to move to supporting a second referendum.

Even so, he’ll come under pressure from many in his party to do so after Labour members voted at their conference last year that it should be an option. On Wednesday morning, more than 100 Labour MPs will call for Brexit to go back to the people.

“The time is now to pivot to support a public vote on whether we should accept the deal or remain in the EU,” said Mike Buckley, director of Labour for a People’s Vote. If Labour doesn’t shift its position, pro-EU lawmakers in the party are planning to propose their own amendment to the next Brexit vote.

May’s government is likewise split. Her Cabinet meeting on Tuesday saw Pensions Secretary Amber Rudd arguing that the prime minister should publicly reject the idea of a no-deal Brexit.


poll image

How do you think the U.K. will most likely proceed in the Brexit process?

    Total Results: 0

    Angry Executives

    In a conference call with business leaders late Tuesday, Chancellor of the Exchequer Philip Hammond floated the idea of delaying Britain’s departure from the EU. Adam Marshall, director-general of the British Chambers of Commerce, said after the vote that businesses he represents were frustrated, impatient and angry. He called it “a high-stakes political roller-coaster ride that shows no sign of stopping.”

    For May, much will also depend on how the EU responds to any new requests. Irish Foreign Minister Simon Coveney said on RTE radio on Wednesday his government was prepared to be helpful to May but was not prepared to change the agreed deal significantly. He also said Ireland wouldn’t block a U.K. request to delay -- but that there must be a plan for a predictable Brexit to grant it.

    The EU is “fearing more than ever” a no-deal Brexit, the bloc’s chief negotiator, Michel Barnier, told the European Parliament in Strasbourg, adding that it was now up to the U.K. to find a way forward. “We are still focused on avoiding that scenario.”