Business

Ecuadorian politicians warn about legal provisions in free trade deal

Updated: 

Published: 

Minister of International Trade Maninder Sidhu responds to a question during question period in the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Monday, April 27, 2026. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick

OTTAWA — Twenty-five former cabinet ministers and former heads of parliament in Ecuador are warning that some provisions in the Canada-Ecuador free trade deal are putting the countries’ economic relationship at risk.

The two countries signed a free trade deal in July. Several Canadian organizations and civil society leaders have warned that the deal threatens the environment and could exacerbate a human rights crisis in the South American country.

In a letter to International Trade Minister Maninder Sidhu, 25 Ecuadorian politicians object to the inclusion of investor-state dispute settlement provisions in the deal and urge the government to remove those sections before ratifying it.

The letter says the provisions, which would allow foreign investors to sue governments through an international tribunal instead of through domestic sovereign courts, are unconstitutional in Ecuador and have been rejected by Ecuadorian voters in several referendums.

“We are not opposed to Canadian investment in Ecuador or to closer economic relations between our two countries,” says the letter. “We write because we believe this agreement, as currently structured, places that relationship at risk.”

The Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives says the provisions were requested by the mining industry and opposed by human rights organizations during public consultations held in 2023.

Stuart Trew, the organization’s senior researcher, said investor-state dispute settlement provisions won’t enhance investment in either country.

“It just gives these companies a real sharp tool they can use to basically threaten countries away from policies they don’t want to see introduced,” said Trew. “We’re quite alarmed by what the Canadian government has done here.”

While the letter says Canada and Ecuador have substantial shared interests in trade, investment and development, it urges a cautious approach to what it calls “an instrument likely to be contested for the duration of its life.”

“An agreement built on sound legal and democratic foundations will serve the relationship between our countries considerably better than one that invites constitutional challenge from the day it enters into force,” says the letter.

Mujtaba Hussain, a spokesperson for International Trade Minister Maninder Sidhu, said in an email the Canada-Ecuador free trade agreement will support “long-term sustainable and inclusive bilateral economic growth.”

He said investor-state dispute settlement tribunals will not be able to repeal laws or regulations and will only be able to award monetary damages to investors in the event of a breach by either party.

“Canada considers that clear and balanced rules, supported by an effective dispute settlement mechanism, are key to a stable investment environment,” said Hussain.

Hussain said the Canada-Ecuador free trade agreement also makes arbitration proceedings more transparent and requires that arbitration hearings be open to the public and civil society.

“The Government of Canada expects all Canadian companies operating abroad to abide by all relevant laws, respect human rights in their operations, and adopt best practices and internationally respected guidelines on responsible business conduct,” he said.

Catherine Morrison, The Canadian Press