Politics

Alberta introduces new electoral boundaries bill, NDP vows court challenge

Published: 

A hot air balloon passes behind the Alberta legislature, in Edmonton, on Tuesday, Aug. 18, 2026. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Darryl Dyck

Alberta’s United Conservative government is moving ahead with controversial changes to the province’s electoral map, setting the stage for a legal battle over whether the proposed boundaries violate voters’ constitutional rights.

Bill 40, the Electoral Divisions Act, would replace Alberta’s existing 87 electoral districts with 91 ridings based on recommendations from an advisory panel whose report was submitted to the legislature Nov. 2.

The legislation follows months of controversy after Premier Danielle Smith’s government rejected recommendations from an independent electoral boundaries commission and appointed a new panel to redraw the map.

If passed, Bill 40 will create several hybrid constituencies combining urban and rural communities, including significant changes in Calgary, Edmonton and Lethbridge.

Justice Minister Mickey Amery says the changes are necessary to ensure Albertans receive effective representation as the province’s population grows.

But Opposition NDP Leader Naheed Nenshi says the government is manipulating electoral boundaries for political advantage.

“If this passes, we’re challenging it in court,” Nenshi told reporters Monday.

Nenshi said the party is considering its legal options, which could include seeking an injunction or pursuing an expedited court hearing.

The timing presents an additional challenge, Nenshi said, with Alberta’s next provincial election scheduled for Oct. 18, 2027.

“We are running out of time, and that is an incredibly unfair position to put a judge in, to put the courts in, and to put Albertans in,” he said.

Elections Alberta has previously warned that implementing new boundaries requires extensive preparations, including changes to polling locations, staffing, electoral maps and computer systems.

Constitutional questions

University of Calgary constitutional law professor Kathleen Mahoney says a court challenge could raise fundamental questions about Albertans’ democratic rights, but proving the new electoral boundaries are unconstitutional would require evidence.

Mahoney explained Section 3 of Canada’s Charter of Rights and Freedoms protects a citizen’s right to vote — but there are more protections than simply one’s ability to cast a ballot.

“Section 3’s wording basically says people are entitled to vote, but when that’s been interpreted by the Supreme Court of Canada, they say that effective representation requires more than just ensuring that people can vote,” Mahoney told CTV News.

The Charter also includes consideration of geography, minority rights and the differing interests of urban and rural communities.

“The community interests of people in rural areas are often much different than community interests in urban areas,” Mahoney said, adding that means effective representation aims to ensure those different interests are “reflected in the way in which electoral boundaries are drawn.”

Differences in riding populations don’t automatically violate the Charter, Mahoney said. Rural constituencies may legitimately have fewer voters because of geographical challenges and the difficulty of ensuring residents can be heard.

But she says the government’s decision to replace the original commission’s recommendations creates another issue for the courts to consider.

“If you compare these two reports, you compare the way in which the electoral map has been redrawn, and if it appears that it’s been done not for more effective representation, but for political advantage, then it could run afoul of Section 3 as well.”

Mahoney says lawyers could examine historical voting patterns to determine whether the new boundaries provide an electoral advantage to the sitting UCP government.

If it looks like electoral districts were manipulated for political advantage over effective representation, a judge could find the redrawing of the map to be unconstitutional, she said.

Mahoney says a constitutional challenge could ultimately reach the Supreme Court of Canada, potentially complicating next year’s election. But she says the courts have options to accelerate proceedings in the right circumstances, such as a looming election.

The new boundaries take effect only when the election writ is issued. Mahoney says that wouldn’t necessarily prevent an earlier constitutional challenge.

Ultimately, Mahoney says the issue is about the full meaning of the constitutional right to vote.

“A lot of people just think… filling out a ballot is what they’re given in the Constitution, but they’re given more than that,” she said.

“The right to vote is bigger than that.”

Public interest group prepares to challenge boundaries

Public Interest Alberta is preparing to challenge the proposed electoral boundaries both in the court of public opinion and potentially in the courthouse.

Executive director Bradley Lafortune says the organization is examining a constitutional challenge while also preparing to make its case publicly against the government’s proposed electoral map.

“A Charter challenge is still something that Public Interest Alberta is very seriously considering,” Lafortune told CTV News.

Lafortune says the government’s new maps disregard the extensive public consultation undertaken by the original Electoral Boundaries Commission.

That original commission heard from over 2,000 people, he said. The Nov. 2 report “completely throws (that input) out the window.”

He says the proposed hybrid ridings could leave MLAs struggling to represent constituents with substantially different needs.

Lafortune also questions the significant population differences between some proposed constituencies, arguing they could dilute the voting power of people in more heavily populated urban ridings.

“If I live in rural Alberta, and my riding has 30,000 people in it, but you live in urban Alberta and your riding has 60,000 people in it, my vote counts for a lot more, because I am being represented by an MLA who represents 30,000, you’re being represented by an MLA who represents 60,000,” he said.

Banff-Kananaskis is another proposed constituency that has what he considers problematic boundaries. Highway 40 through Highwood Pass, a key connection between communities in the proposed riding, is closed seasonally.

Lafortune says the organization is considering its options for responding to the legislation, but isn’t prepared to disclose its legal strategy.

He said Public Interest Alberta intends to pursue its concerns independently of political parties.

“This is not a partisan issue, this is an issue of democracy,” he said.

Competing recommendations

The controversy began when the original Electoral Boundaries Commission recommended increasing the number of constituencies from 87 to 89.

Its majority report proposed adding seats in Calgary and Edmonton while eliminating two rural constituencies to reflect population changes.

Commission chair Justice Dallas Miller subsequently recommended increasing the total to 91 seats as a way of preserving the two rural ridings.

The government instead established a new advisory panel, which recommended a substantially different electoral map.

The panel’s November report proposes retaining rural representation while creating additional hybrid ridings that combine portions of cities with surrounding rural areas.

Under the proposal, Lethbridge would be divided among four constituencies instead of its current two, with several of the new ridings extending into surrounding rural communities.

The changes have generated concerns about whether urban and rural voters with different priorities can be effectively represented by the same MLA.

Smith has defended the use of hybrid constituencies, noting they already exist in Alberta, including in her own riding of Brooks-Medicine Hat.

The government says the advisory panel was directed to consider population, geography, transportation, communities of interest and the constitutional requirement for effective representation.

Nenshi maintains the changes are designed to benefit the governing party.

“There’s a very simple rule in a democracy, voters choose their politicians,” he said Monday. “The UCP has tried to have politicians choose their voters.”

The government says the legislation will give MLAs an opportunity to debate the proposed boundaries and provide certainty ahead of next year’s election.

If Bill 40 passes, the new electoral boundaries would take effect when the election writ is issued, expected Sept. 20, 2027, ahead of the scheduled Oct. 18 provincial election.

Whether those boundaries ultimately withstand a constitutional challenge remains an open question.