Opinion

Stan Wong: Tax-loss selling – when does it make sense to sell at a loss?

Published: 

A T1 General tax form is shown in this file photo. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Graeme Roy

A stock you bought at $50 now trades at $35. If you had the cash today, would you buy it at $35?

When I review a stock that’s down, I look at what’s changed in the earnings outlook, what the lower price already reflects and where else I could put the money. If the case for owning it has weakened, it may be time to sell.

If you’ve decided to sell, the loss may still be worth something at tax time. If you hold the stock in a non-registered account, you can generally use the realized loss to offset capital gains. Losses inside a TFSA, RRSP or other registered account can’t be used this way.

Why year-end timing matters

To use a loss against this year’s gains, the sale must settle before year-end.

Wednesday, Dec. 30, 2026, is the last trading day to sell most stocks and ETFs listed in Canada (TSX and TSX Venture) or the U.S. (NYSE and Nasdaq) for a sale to count in the 2026 Canadian tax year.

These trades normally settle one business day later, on Thursday, Dec. 31.

Work out what the loss can offset

Suppose you realized a $20,000 capital gain earlier this year. You then sell another investment in a non-registered account for an $8,000 capital loss. That brings your net capital gain to $12,000 before applying the capital gains inclusion rate.

If your capital losses exceed your gains this year, you can generally carry the net capital loss back to offset taxable capital gains from any of the previous three years or carry it forward indefinitely.

For a loss realized in 2026, that means looking back at 2023, 2024 and 2025. A gain from selling a cottage or rental property may be easy to overlook when you’re focused on your brokerage statement.

Confirm you have a loss in Canadian dollars

A U.S. stock can fall five per cent and still leave you with a capital gain in Canadian dollars. Say you bought it at US$100 when one U.S. dollar was worth $1.30, then sold it at US$95 when the exchange rate was $1.40. Your cost was $130 and your proceeds were $133 per share, leaving a small capital gain before trading costs.

Before placing a trade, verify the investment’s adjusted cost base. If you bought the same stock at different prices, generally use the weighted average across your non-registered accounts.

Look across accounts before you sell

Canada’s superficial loss rule can deny the loss if you or an affiliated person, such as your spouse or common-law partner, buys the same or an identical investment within 30 calendar days before or after the sale, and either of you still owns it 30 days after the sale.

Check both partners’ accounts for recent trades and scheduled purchases, including dividend reinvestments.

If you contribute an investment at a loss directly from a non-registered account to your TFSA or RRSP, you give up the capital loss. Selling it first and contributing cash, if you have contribution room, can preserve the loss, provided the superficial loss rule doesn’t apply.

Keep the exposure you still want

If you sell a stock at a loss but still see opportunity in its industry, you could reinvest the proceeds in a peer with a similar business. Consider whether its earnings outlook and valuation justify the purchase.

You could also buy a diversified sector ETF that holds the stock you sold. That would give you some exposure if the original stock rebounds while spreading the investment across several companies.

A Canadian depositary receipt (CDR), however, represents a direct interest in the underlying shares. If those are the same shares you sold, the CDR can be treated as identical property and trigger the superficial loss rule.

Tax-loss selling can be part of a total wealth plan, whether you’re trimming a concentrated position or raising cash for a planned expense. Your tax advisor can help you assess the value of the loss, and your wealth advisor can help you decide where the proceeds would serve you best.

If you’re still weighing whether to sell, start where we began. Would you buy the stock at today’s price?