If a company has any exposure in Russia, a board meeting should be held: Governance expert
McDonald’s Corp., Coca-Cola Co. and Starbucks Corp. are temporarily halting business operations in Russia amid an intensifying backlash since the invasion of Ukraine started nearly two weeks ago.
The iconic U.S. brands, seen around the world as the face of U.S. capitalism, announced their decisions in a flurry of announcements on Tuesday afternoon, joining hundreds of other global companies that have halted work in Russia since the war began. PepsiCo Inc. said it would suspend soft drink sales in Russia but would continue to sell daily essentials such as milk and baby formula.
After days of criticism on social media, companies with larger or more entrenched operations in Russia are starting to relent as the death toll rises in Ukraine and millions of refugees flee. The moves to step back from Russia will further isolate the nation of 144 million people, which is the world’s 11th-largest economy.
Some companies’ withdrawal makes it easier for others to do the same, given interconnected supply chains, said Gene Grabowski, a partner at communications firm KGlobal. Coca-Cola, for example, is a supplier for McDonald’s, so McDonald’s action deprives it of a major client in the country.“What you’re seeing is a confluence here. Now it makes business sense,” said Grabowski, who has more than 30 years of crisis-management experience. “Now there’s a business argument as well as an argument of conscience.”
Here are some of the other major companies that have recently announced a scaling back of Russia operations.
- Yum! Brands Inc. temporarily shuttered the KFC restaurants it owns in Russia and said it’s near an agreement with its franchisee to suspend Pizza Hut operations there. The company had earlier said it would pause investment and restaurant development in Russia and channel all profits there into humanitarian efforts.
- Paypal Holdings Inc. said it’s suspending services in the country. The company said it can’t “reasonably estimate the total potential financial impact that may ultimately result from this situation.”
- Amazon.com Inc.’s cloud-computing unit announced it will stop accepting new customers in Russia or Belarus, according to a company blog post. The company said its Amazon Web Services unit had “no data centers, infrastructure or offices in Russia, and we have a long-standing policy of not doing business with the Russian government. We have also stopped allowing new sign-ups for AWS in Russia and Belarus.”
- Rolex, the biggest luxury Swiss watch brand, will halt exports to Russia, joining peers Swatch Group and Richemont. The only Rolex watches currently being sold in Russia are by independent and privately owned local retailers with inventory that was delivered before the invasion, the company said.
- L’Oreal temporarily closed its own brand stores and e-commerce brand sites in Russia. It also closed some points of sale it operates in deparment stores.
Some companies left the door open to resume operations in Russia quickly if circumstances change. McDonald’s and Starbucks said they will continue to pay workers while closing their locations in the country. That could erode profitability if the companies can’t return to normal business for a prolonged period.
Cowen Inc. analyst Andrew Charles said last week that the exposure to Russia and Ukraine is “immaterial” to McDonald’s even though it represents about 9 per cent of the company’s revenue. That’s because the countries account for less than 3 per cent of operating profit, or US$311 million of the US$10.4 billion in operating profit that McDonald’s reported last year.
James Rutherford, an analyst with Stephens, said that McDonald’s decision to forgo sales and continue paying staff “could temporarily cause a more pronounced impact on operating income than the 3 per cent operating income mix would suggest.” However, this may be at least partially offset by the decline of the ruble versus the dollar, he wrote in a research note.
Some companies made a point of simultaneously denouncing the Russian invasion of Ukraine while stressing they don’t want to neglect the basic needs of consumers in Russia because of the actions of their government
“As a food and beverage company, now more than ever we must stay true to the humanitarian aspect of our business,” Chief Executive Officer Ramon Laguarta said in a memo to employees. “That means we have a responsibility to continue to offer our other products in Russia, including daily essentials such as milk and other dairy offerings, baby formula and baby food.”
Tuesday’s wave of departures follow earlier announcements by companies including Nike Inc. and Apple Inc. It’s proven hard for big global brands to walk away from decades of brand-building that date back to the fall of the Soviet Union, according to Jeffrey Sonnenfeld, a Yale University business professor
“A lot of the consumer-goods companies were waiting until the 11th hour, they were late to the party, and there were reasons why,” he said in an interview. “They were afraid, having worked so hard to build these iconic brands.”