Mar 19, 2020
Reducing liquor store hours could undermine containment efforts, says epidemiologist
The Canadian Press
Cutting liquor store hours amounts to a half-measure that could undermine efforts to contain COVID-19, epidemiologists say.
"Reducing hours and concentrating customers into crowded times makes no sense, as would forming lines outside," said Donald Milton, who studies the spread of virus particles at the University of Maryland.
Milton said the potential for crammed spaces risks spreading the virus, which has infected more than 730 Canadians and killed nine.
He recommends either closing stores entirely or maintaining regular or extended hours.
Government-run liquor stores in provinces including Ontario, Quebec and Nova Scotia are scaling back operations, opening their doors for between seven and nine hours on most days as a preventative measure.
Prince Edward Island has gone further, announcing Wednesday that all non-essential services -- including liquor stores -- would be closed by Thursday afternoon.
Within hours, Charlottetown shoppers were standing in line to stock up on beer and spirits before the window of less than 24 hours closed.
"I have to say I'm disappointed in Islanders' response in the last three hours," provincial chief health officer Heather Morrison said at a press briefing Wednesday evening.
"We have talked about social distancing. We have talked about the importance of staying home unless it's essential. That appears to have been ignored."
Morrison said the province is looking at alternative options, including online sale.
Stephen Hoption Cann of the University of British Columbia's school of population and public health suggested PEI may have acted too drastically. "Those sorts of interruptions can lead to panic buying, like we have seen with toilet paper."
While liquor provision may not be considered an essential service, another key question is what keeping stores open means for public health.
Small numbers of people spread throughout the store and interacting two-and-a-half metres apart are not generally a public health problem, said Boris Lushniak, dean of the University of Maryland's school of public health. Extra caution should be taken at the checkout counter, he said.
"I admit that I like to have a glass of beer or a glass of wine on occasion," said Lushniak, a former U.S. deputy surgeon-general. "But do I deem liquor stores to be essential? The answer is, to be frank, no. But it's still not an easy decision on liquor store closures."
The Newfoundland and Labrador Liquor Corporation will shut its retail outlets Saturday and is rolling out a plan for phone and online delivery.
Meanwhile, provincial Crown corporations in Ontario and Quebec are managing traffic flow to avoid crowding. The Societe des alcools du Quebec (SAQ) now lets in between 10 and 50 customers at one time, depending on store size. It also no longer accepts cash.
The Nova Scotia Liquor Corporation has designated a one-hour shopping window starting at 10 a.m. for seniors and other consumers at a higher risk of contracting the virus.
Alberta has chosen to stay the course, however, with Alberta Gaming, Liquor and Cannabis spokeswoman Heather Holmen stating that retail stores "are not impacted at this time."
Scheduled charitable casino events will also roll out as planned, the agency said.
Next door, the B.C. Lottery Corporation closed all casinos as well as community gaming centres and bingo halls on Monday. But the BC Liquor Distribution Branch continues to operate as usual, outside of heightened hygiene measures.