David Baskin discusses BlackBerry
Prem Watsa’s nemesis is back, and this time he’s urging other shareholders of BlackBerry Ltd. to push the investor out of his longtime board role.
Dorsey Gardner, a veteran analyst and fund manager with about five million shares of the Canadian software company, said investors should follow the advice of Glass Lewis & Co. and withhold their votes for Watsa as lead director. The proxy advisory firm says Watsa shouldn’t be re-elected to the role he’s held since 2013 because of executive pay that isn’t aligned with performance.
Watsa “is plainly unfit to serve as a director of the company, let alone its lead director and chair of the compensation, nomination and governance committee,” Gardner said in a written statement Monday.
Among Gardner’s complaints is the way Watsa’s investment and insurance company, Fairfax Financial Holdings Ltd., was allowed to buy up convertible debt from BlackBerry last year. The debt, which carries a conversion price of US$6 a share, was a “sweetheart deal for Fairfax,” Gardner said. BlackBerry closed at US$12.80 in New York on Monday.
Gardner fought the company over the financing last year. BlackBerry ultimately revised the terms, but the convertible deal allows Fairfax, which already owns about eight per cent of BlackBerry’s shares, to boost its ownership to more than 15 per cent.
“Fairfax has significantly increased its stake, at a low price, paving the way for it to potentially make a lowball offer for BlackBerry’s remaining outstanding shares,” Gardner said in his Monday statement. The financing “was manifestly unfair to minority shareholders and the product of serious breaches of Watsa’s and all BlackBerry directors’ fiduciary duties of loyalty.”
Representatives for BlackBerry and Fairfax did not immediately return requests for comment. Gardner, through his lawyer, declined to comment beyond his written statement. BlackBerry’s shareholder meeting is scheduled for June 23.