Feb 2, 2023
Lula Says Brazil Needs More Tools to Fight Inflation
(Bloomberg) -- Brazil’s swap rates rose further after President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva bolstered criticism of the central bank, saying high interest rates are ruining the economy while failing to control inflation.
The leftist president elaborated on previous criticism of the monetary authority in a message sent to lawmakers on Thursday afternoon and then in a TV interview broadcast late on the same day. Swap rates, which had already been rising since the central bank vowed to keep its key rate unchanged until inflation expectations converge to target, extended gains after his comments.
Contracts maturing in January 2027 jumped as much as 25 basis points, while those expiring in January 2024, which signal investor expectations for the Selic rate at the end of the year, were up 6 basis points at 1:24 p.m. in Sao Paulo. The country’s curve shows declining bets that policy makers will start cutting the benchmark rate, which currently sits at 13.75%.
“Investors are already worried about Lula’s fiscal policy, the last thing they want to see is a political attack on monetary policy,” said Win Thin, head of currency strategy at Brown Brothers Harriman & Co. in New York.
Fiscal and economic policy concerns had Brazil missing out on a strong start to the year for emerging markets. The MSCI Brazil Index is up 2.5% since the beginning of the year, lagging an 8.4% jump for its developing-nation benchmark. The real has been underperforming regional peers such as the Chilean, Colombian and Mexican pesos.
Lula had initially raised investor concerns two weeks ago, when calling the central bank’s recently approved autonomy law “nonsense” and saying too tight inflation targets were “choking the economy.” On Thursday, he said in an interview to Rede TV/UOL that central bank chief Roberto Campos Neto “has to explain why keeping an interest rate of 13.75%, and why the possibility of additional hikes if we don’t have demand inflation.”
Read More: Brazil Industry Stalls, Hindering Lula’s Efforts to Grow Economy
He added that he intends to have a meeting with banks and businesspeople to discuss Brazil’s monetary policy because “there’s no reason for interest rates to stand at 13.75%.”
‘Active’ FX Policy
Earlier on Thursday, Lula defended the use of additional tools besides interest rates to rein in inflation, including a more active policy to reduce foreign-exchange volatility and the regulation of fuel prices and food stocks.
In a 180-page message to lawmakers, he blamed his predecessor Jair Bolsonaro for abandoning the use of “important instruments to fight inflation,” leading to an over-reliance on high interest rates that are hurting the economy. He also said a more stable currency would help mitigate inflation.
“A more passive exchange-rate policy in recent years has accentuated the volatility of the Brazilian currency against the dollar, with perverse consequences for prices,” Lula said in the message delivered by his Chief of Staff Rui Costa at the beginning of the congressional year.
Read More: Lula Squandered Rate Cut Chance, His Ex-Central Bank Chief Says
In his message, Lula said Latin America’s largest economy lost its ability to smooth out swings in prices of food and fuel when the government cut down on grain storage facilities and changed the corporate focus of state-owned Petroleo Brasileiro SA, making it more dependent on imports.
In addition, the Bolsonaro administration “abandoned sector-specific policies to induce an increase in the production of critical goods,” the message read. “On the other hand, it implemented a policy of high interest rates that slowed down the economic recovery and increased unemployment with little impact on inflation, which was basically caused by a supply shock.”
Lula promised to resume policies to regulate the supply of critical products, including the storage of grains and the expansion of financing for food production. He also suggested a transition to a new fuel pricing policy that takes into account local costs and encourages investment in refining and distribution.
At this moment, Lula may not want to spend his political capital trying to remove the central bank’s autonomy, but there’s room for the government to consider reviewing inflation goals, according to Andre Raduan, a partner and portfolio manager at hedge fund Genoa Capital. “His rhetoric should remain fiery,” Raduan said at an event earlier this week.
--With assistance from Martha Beck, Fernando Travaglini and Felipe Saturnino.
(Updates market move, adds context and comments from portfolio manager starting in third paragraph.)
©2023 Bloomberg L.P.
BNN Bloomberg Picks
Energy stocks to hold for the long haul: Three hot picks from Cole Smead
Margaret Franklin on rebranding finance as a career for women
Powell hedged his bet of a soft landing: Larry Berman
Is your retirement portfolio ready for what's to come?
Investment opportunities in cannabis stocks: Three hot picks from Matt Bottomley
What happens if you mistakenly get a larger tax refund?