OPEC+ talks were unexpectedly suspended on Monday after a majority of members, including Saudi Arabia, opposed Russia’s proposal for a February supply hike.

Discussions will resume on Tuesday, giving the group more time to resolve differences over how much extra oil the market can take as the accelerating coronavirus pandemic threatens a wave of tighter lockdowns.

The extension of talks casts doubt on the production increase of 500,000 barrels a day the market had been expecting for February. It also calls into question similar supply boosts traders had penciled in for March and April.

Differences of opinion between Saudi Arabia and Russia, the two de-facto leaders of OPEC+, can make for tricky meetings. While Moscow appeared to be outnumbered on this occasion, the group typically requires a consensus among all members before concluding talks. Failure to reach a compromise is rare but can have damaging consequences, notably last year’s month-long price war.

Before ministers gather again on Tuesday, they will have the chance to hold bilateral talks and consult with their home governments, delegates said.

In Monday’s video conference, the initial positions of Moscow and Riyadh were diametrically opposed. Saudi Energy Minister Prince Abdulaziz bin Salman proposed rolling back the 500,000 barrel-a-day production increase the group made this month, delegates said. His Russian counterpart, Deputy Prime Minister Alexander Novak wanted to maintain that supply hike and add the same again in February.

Urging Caution

In his opening remarks, Prince Abdulaziz highlighted the risks to the oil market from a more infectious strain of the coronavirus, which has heightened the economic risks even as the roll-out of vaccines has buoyed prices.

“At the risk of being seen as a killjoy in the proceedings, I want to urge caution,” he said. “The new variant of the virus is a worrying and unpredictable development.”

The prince, who has consistently sought to keep a tight rein on supply, also indicated he would accept rolling over current output levels into February, they said. Algeria, Nigeria, Oman, Iraq, Kuwait and the United Arab Emirates were also in favor of holding supply steady, delegates said, asking not to be named because the meeting was private. Kazakhstan supported Novak’s position.

“Russia is currently focusing on market share while a number of other countries value prices,” Iran’s Oil Minister Bijan Namdar Zanganeh told reporters, according to the ministry’s news service Shana.

The Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries and its allies are currently idling 7.2 million barrels a day, or about 7 per cent of world supplies, and had planned to return a further 1.5 million barrels a day in installments over the coming months.

The group is already taking a cautious approach, agreeing in December to meet every month -- rather than just a few times a year -- in order to fine-tune production levels more precisely and avoid capsizing the price recovery they spent most of 2020 working to achieve.

Other prominent voices from the alliance have echoed Prince Abdulaziz’s caution. “There’s a need to be wary of the repercussions of the second wave of the pandemic,” state-run Kuwait News Agency reported on Monday, citing a statement from Oil Minister Mohammed Alfares.

OPEC Secretary-General Mohammad Barkindo said at Sunday’s preparatory meeting that “there are still many downside risks to juggle.”

Tighter Lockdowns

Brent crude, the international benchmark, fell 1.8 per cent to US$50.87 a barrel on Monday. Prices rallied earlier in the day on strong demand from Asia due to freezing weather, but faltered later amid signs of tighter lockdowns in Europe.

The case for another small OPEC+ output increase in February is underpinned by a recovery in the oil prices, which have gained more than a third since the emergence of the first COVID vaccines last year.

Russia’s Novak said last month that OPEC+ should proceed with its supply increase because prices are in an optimal range of US$45 to US$55 a barrel. If OPEC+ refrains from bolstering exports, its competitors will simply fill the gap, he said.

Yet there are also reasons to think the group will take a more cautious approach.

Restrictions on movement are still in place in a number of countries amid a new strain of the virus, Barkindo said. It’s too soon to know how key sectors of the economy will be affected, and for the tourism and leisure industries the return to pre-crisis levels could take a couple of years.

Oil inventories in developed nations remain 163 million barrels above their five-year average, Barkindo added. Despite the market’s rebound, crude prices are far below the levels most OPEC members need to cover government spending.

“With headlines regarding surging virus cases in the western world being joined by concerns emanating from Asia, including Thailand and Japan, OPEC+ is keen to take a cautious approach, a stance supported by Saudi Arabia,” said Amrita Sen, co-founder of consultant Energy Aspects Ltd. in London.